In the bottom of the fourth inning of Game 2 of the National League Division Series, pitcher Travis Wood of the Chicago Cubs launched a solo home run off George Kontos of the San Francisco Giants. Wood’s long ball was the first homer by a relief pitcher in a postseason game since 1924 when Rosy Ryan of the New York Giants hit a solo home run off Allen Russell of the Washington Senators.
In Game 3 of the same Division Series, Jake Arrieta of the Cubs also connected for a homer, a three-run shot off Madison Bumgarner in the top of the second inning. Wood and Arrieta became the first two pitchers from the same team to homer in the same postseason series since Jack Bentley joined Ryan in the homer parade with a two-run shot off Walter Johnson in Game 5 of the 1924 World Series.
There have been 15 home runs by 13 different pitchers in the World Series; Bob Gibson of the St. Louis Cardinals and Dave McNally of the Baltimore Orioles each did it twice. There have been six home runs by pitchers in the League Championship Series, while the home runs by Wood and Arrieta are the first by pitchers in a Division Series.
Jim Bagby of the Cleveland Indians was the first pitcher to homer in the Fall Classic; he connected for a two-run shot off Burleigh Grimes of the Brooklyn Robins in the bottom of the fourth inning of Game 5 of the 1920 World Series.
Gibson and McNally are the only pitchers to hit home runs in two different World Series. Gibson hit a solo home run off Jim Lonborg of the Boston Red Sox in the top of the fifth inning of Game 7 of the 1967 Series. The next season, Gibson hit a solo homer off Joe Sparma of the Detroit Tigers in the top of the fourth inning of Game 4. Home runs were nothing special for Gibson; he slammed 24 regular-season homers during his career.
McNally hit the first of his World Series home runs in Game 5 in 1969. It was a two-run homer off Jerry Koosman of the New York Mets. In Game 3 of the 1970 World Series, McNally connected for his second Series homer, a grand slam no less, against Wayne Granger of the Cincinnati Reds in the bottom of the sixth inning.
Twice in the World Series a pitcher from each team has hit a home run. In the bottom of the third inning of Game 1 of the 1967 Series José Santiago of the Red Sox accounted for his team’s only run with a solo home run off Gibson who, as mentioned earlier, would go on to hit a homer of his own in Game 7. Gibson is the only pitcher to hit a home run and give up a home run to a pitcher in the World Series.
In the top of the third inning of Game 2 of the 1968 World Series Mickey Lolich of the Tigers hit a solo home run off Nelson Briles of the Cardinals. As mentioned earlier, Gibson hit a home run in Game 7 of that Series.
From 1967-1970 Santiago, Gibson, Lolich, and McNally put together a streak of four straight World Series in which a pitcher hit a home run. And since Gibson and McNally hit two home runs apiece during this span, these four years account for 40 percent of the World Series homers.
Mike Cuellar of the Orioles hit the first home run by a pitcher in a League Championship Series. In the top of the fourth inning of the 1970 ALCS, Cuellar hit a grand slam off Jim Perry of the Minnesota Twins. As mentioned earlier, his teammate Dave McNally hit a home run, also a grand slam, in the World Series that year. So not only did Cuellar and McNally homer in the same postseason, but also both of their home runs were grand slams.
With the Wild Card Games, Division Series, League Championship Series, and World Series, the chance for postseason home runs by pitchers has greatly increased since the days of Ryan and Bentley. But with the dreaded designated hitter in use for over half of those postseason games, the likelihood of home runs by pitchers still remains fairly remote.
If you live within a day’s drive of Nashville, Tenn., then you should plan a trip to the Nashville Public Library to check out “PLAY! The Art of Mike Schacht.” This exhibit features over 100 items from Mike Scahacht (1936-2001), who created memorable works of art for the Baseball Hall of Fame and Upper Deck.
Mr. Scahacht created paintings of some of the legendary players from the history of baseball, including Ty Cobb, Henry Aaron, Willie Mays, and Ted Williams. He also recreated many of the game’s memorable moments. Mr. Schacht was the creator of Fan magazine, a baseball art and literary triannual.
The exhibit is open to the public, free of charge, from now until December 31, 2016, in the Courtyard Gallery of the Main Library, 615 Church Street in Nashville.
The Atlanta Braves finished the 2016 season in last place in the National League Eastern Division with a record of 68-93 and 26.5 games out of first; but it could have been much worse.
The Braves got out of the gate with a 9-28 record that led to the firing of manager Fredi Gonzalez. At the time of Gonzalez’s departure, the Braves were on pace to lose 123 games, which would have been the most in the history of modern baseball.
While it stood to reason the Braves would not lose quite that many games, they seemed certain to lose over 100 games for the first time since 1988 when they dropped 108 and finished 39.5 games out of first place. The Braves played somewhat better under new manager Brian Snitker, but their record at the end of July was only 37-68, which put them on pace to lose 105 games. But a funny thing happened over the last two months of the season; the Braves started playing decent baseball.
From August 1 through the end of the season, the Braves went 31-25. They were 17-10 in September and won 12 of their final 14 games. All talk of the Braves just phoning it in to get the top pick in the amateur draft vanished.
The turnaround by the Braves coincided with their acquisition of Matt Kemp from the San Diego Padres. Kemp, who came to the team with a decent 23 homers, 69 RBIs, and .262 average, slammed 10 home runs, drove in 35 runs, and hit .280 after the trade. Hitting fourth in the lineup seemed to spur on Freddie Freeman, who hit .358 with eight homers and 29 RBIs in his final 30 games and was the National League Player of the Month for September. Freeman finished the season at .302 with 34 home runs and 91 RBIs.
Ender Inciarte got off to a slow start due to an injury, but Snitker put him in the leadoff spot late in the season and he hit .317 over his last 30 games to finish at .291. He played excellent defense in center field, as well.
Right fielder, Nick Markakis, hit 13 home runs and quietly drove in 89 runs and third baseman, Adonis Garcia, provided plenty of pop batting second in the order; he hit 12 homers and drove in 65 runs.
Another key to the Braves’ improvement was the promotion of shortstop Dansby Swanson. After joining the Braves on August 17, Swanson hit .302 with three home runs and 17 RBIs. His play at short steadily improved to the point that the Detroit Tigers will have nightmares about his glove work all winter long.
The Braves started holding onto leads late in the game thanks to the resurgence of closer, Jim Johnson. In his final 30 appearances, Johnson notched 18 of his 20 saves for the season and struck out 39 batters in 30 1/3 innings; his ERA over that stretch was 1.48. Johnson was so impressive that the Braves signed him to a two-year deal during the final weekend of the season.
After such a dismal start, when the dust finally settled on the 2016 season, not only had the Braves avoided 100 losses, but they also wound up winning one more game than they did last season.
Obviously, the Braves still have their work cut out for them to be a contender in 2017 when they move up the road to their new park. But with their strong finish, the Braves left their fans with some reason to feel optimistic during the long off-season.
The Giants Are Not a Dynasty
Let me go ahead and get this out of the way right now. The San Francisco Giants are back in the postseason as the second Wild Card team. They travel to the Big Apple to play the New York Mets this Wednesday. If they make it all the way through the postseason and win another World Series title, they will have won four Series in the last seven seasons. But that doesn’t make them a dynasty.
The Giants won the National League West in 2010 and had the second best record in the league on their way to the World Series title. They finished in second place in 2011 with the fifth-best record in the league and did not make the playoffs. They won the West again in 2012, tied with the Braves for the third-best record in the league, and went on to win the World Series. They did not make the playoffs in 2013 as they finished fourth in the West with a record of 76-86. In 2014 they finished in second place in the West with the fifth-best record in the league, but that was good enough for the second Wild Card spot. They got hot at the right time and won another World Series title.
While it certainly is impressive to win three World Series titles in five years, they are not even close to being a dynasty. If they had won five straight division titles and strung together three straight World Series wins like the Oakland Athletics (1971-1975 for the division titles and 1972-1974 for the Series), then we could talk about a dynasty. A dynasty does not skip the postseason every other year, especially in this era of the watered-down playoff system.
And while I’m at it, unless Madison Bumgarner pitches at least three complete games and wins them all like Lew Burdette did in 1957 and Mickey Lolich did in 1968, he will not have turned in the “most dominant performance in World Series history.” Even if Bumgarner pulls off three complete-game wins, two of them would have to be shutouts, with his final 24 innings being scoreless for him to match Burdette. And even Burdette’s magnificent performance did not measure up to the three starts, three complete games, and three shutouts by Christy Mathewson in the 1905 Fall Classic.
The Giants have been a good team for four of the last seven seasons; but a dynasty they are not and Madison Bumgarner’s performance in 2014 was not the most dominant in World Series history.
Sunday morning I tapped into my laptop to check the Internet for the late baseball scores only to see that José Fernandez, the young, enthusiastic, and hugely talented right-handed pitcher of the Miami Marlins was killed in an early morning boating accident. He was only 24 years old.
The news knocked the wind out of my sails. Even with his abundant ability the first thing that comes to my mind when I think of this kid is his wonderful smile. I call him a kid, perhaps, because he was the same age as our son. What a heartbreaking loss for his family, for baseball, and for the world.
It is terribly ironic that Fernandez should die of a boating accident off the coast of Florida given his struggles to get to this country from Cuba. He and his family made three failed attempts at reaching the mainland before finally making it in 2007 when Fernandez was 15.
At the time of his death, Fernandez was 16-8 on the season with a 2.86 earned run average. His 253 strikeouts in 182 1/3 innings demonstrate how dominant he had been this season. In his tragically short career Fernandez won 38 games, lost 17, and had a career ERA of 2.58. He was the National League Rookie of the Year and an All Star in 2012; he also was on the All-Star team this year.
Given the number of active players in Major League Baseball, it is inevitable that tragedy will strike from time to time. Most deaths of active players seem to occur during the offseason. Roberto Clemente died on New Year’s Eve in 1972 while on a humanitarian mission to supply aid to earthquake victims in Nicaragua. Pitchers Steve Olin and Tim Crews of the Cleveland Indians died, also in a boating accident, on March 22, 1993 during Spring Training. Unfortunately, in the history of baseball, several players have had their careers ended by tragic deaths during the season.
Before Fernandez the last player to die during the season was Darryl Kile of the St. Louis Cardinals. He died of coronary disease in his Chicago hotel room on June 22, 2002 while the Cardinals were in town for a weekend series with the Cubs. Kile had a career record of 133-119 with three teams over 12 seasons. He was a three-time All Star and won 20 games for the Cardinals in 2000. Kile was 33 years old.
On August 2, 1979 catcher Thurman Munson of the New York Yankees was killed when a plane he was piloting crashed while he was practicing landings at an airport in Canton, Ohio. Munson, who was 32 at the time of his death, was captain of the Yankees, the American League Rookie of the Year in 1970, and the American League MVP in 1976.
Lyman Bostock signed a free agent contract with the California Angels before the 1978 season. He batted .323 in 1976 and .336 in 1977 for the Twins. The left-handed hitting outfielder was fatally shot on September 23, 1978 while sitting in his car at a red light in Gary, Ind. After a slow star for the Angels, Bostock had gotten his average up to .296 at the time of his death. He was 27 hears old.
Native Tennessean Walt Bond was a veteran of the Negro Leagues and a minor league slugger before making it to the majors in 1960 with the Cleveland Indians at the age of 32. The 6’ 7” former Kansas City Monarch played parts of six seasons in the big leagues. Bond smashed 20 homers for the 1964 Houston Colt 45’s. Despite battling leukemia, he was hitting .313 for the Minnesota Twins in 1967 when died on September 14 at the age of 39.
Harry Agganis was the regular first baseman for the Boston Red Sox in his rookie season of 1954. The following year, he was hitting .313 on June 27 when he died of a massive heart attack while in the hospital recovering from pneumonia. Agganis was 25 years old at the time of his death.
Ray Chapman of the Cleveland Indians died on August 17, 1920. He remains the only player ever to be killed during a Major League game. On August 16, Chapman apparently was moving forward in the batter’s box to attempt a drag bunt when an up-and-in fastball from Yankees’ pitcher Carl Mays struck Chapman in the forehead, crushing his skull. He died in the wee hours of the morning despite showing signs of improvement after emergency surgery. The fleet-footed shortstop was 29 years old at the time of his death. He played nine seasons and hit .278 over the course of his career.
On April 14, 1911, pitcher Addie Joss of the Cleveland Naps died suddenly of tubercular meningitis. Joss was all set to start his 10th season in the big leagues, but had not yet appeared in a game for the Naps, whose season began on April 12. He was 190-67 with a microscopic 1.89 ERA at the time of his death; Joss was 31 years old. Unlike the Marlins, the Naps went ahead and played their regularly scheduled game on the day Joss died. Even though he pitched for only nine years, the Veterans’ Committee elected Joss to the Hall of Fame in 1978.
One of baseball’s earliest stars, Big Ed Delahanty, died on July 2, 1903 as a result of a fall from a bridge at Niagara Falls. Delahanty was hitting .333 for the Washington Senators at the time of his death. He played parts of 16 seasons from 1888-1903 and had a career batting average of .346; he hit .404 in 1894 and again in 1895 and hit .410 in 1899. He was 35 years old at the time of his death. Delahanty was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1945.
The death of José Fernandez will affect the Miami Marlins for a long, long time. He was their best player; he was a fan favorite. Fernandez was a huge talent and he seemed to love playing the game more than anybody else in baseball. Of all the deaths of active baseball players, the loss of José Fernandez may be the most tragic. At 24 his baseball star had only just begun to shine. It is said that life “is even a vapour, that appeareth for a little time, and then vanisheth.” But for José Fernandez, that time was way too little.
With apologies to Jimmy Dugan, the fictional manager from the movie A League of Their Own, as of September 25, 2016, there is crying in baseball.
Can it really be 50 years since Tony Cloninger of that Atlanta Braves became the first player in the history of the National League to hit two grand slams in one game? It was quite an accomplishment, especially considering the fact that Cloninger was a pitcher.
Cloninger first came to the big leagues in 1961 and went 7-2 for the Milwaukee Braves. He steadily improved and won 19 games in 1964. His best season was 1965 when he won 24 games.
The Braves moved to Atlanta from Milwaukee in 1966 and brought with them several brand name sluggers, including Henry Aaron, Ed Mathews, and Joe Torre. In the first game in Atlanta Braves’ history, Cloninger battled the hard-hitting Pittsburgh Pirates and pitched a 13-inning complete game. Willie Stargell hit a two-run homer in the top of the thirteenth and the Pirates won the game 3-2. Apparently, the marathon pitching performance took the life out of Cloninger’s pitching arm and he was never quite the same after that game.
Cloninger entered the 1966 season with one career home run, but on June 16 Cloninger clubbed two homers and drove in five runs against the New York Mets. This was the beginning of a hitting tear that would see him drive in 18 runs over the course of five games. Entering the game on July 3 at Candlestick Park in San Francisco, Cloninger was six for his last 16 with two home runs and nine runs batted in.
My brothers and I tuned into the game coming to us from the West Coast on WSM AM 650 out of Nashville. The Braves knocked out Giants’ starter Joe Gibbon after only 2/3 of an inning. With two men on, Bob Priddy replaced Gibbon and promptly made things worse by walking Denis Menke. That brought Cloninger to the plate and he hit a 3-2 pitch over the center-field fence for a grand slam that gave the Braves a 7-0 lead.
In the fourth inning, Cloninger came to bat again with the bases loaded. Ray Sadecki, the Giants’ third pitcher of the evening, got ahead with a strike, but Cloninger blasted the next pitch deep to right-center field and his second grand slam of the game sailed into the night. Cloninger topped off his performance by driving in another run with a single in the eighth inning. In another oddity, Sadecki got in on the home-run act by hitting one of his own in the bottom of the fifth inning.
While Cloninger was the first player in National League history to hit two grand slams in one game, four American Leaguers previously had done it–Tony Lazerri of the New York Yankees in 1936, Jim Tabor of the Boston Red Sox in 1939, Rudy York of the Red Sox in 1946, and Jim Gentile of the Baltimore Orioles in 1961.
Since Cloninger joined the exclusive group of sluggers to hit two grand slams in one game, eight more players joined the club: Jim Northrup of the Detroit Tigers in 1968; Frank Robinson of the Orioles in 1970; Robin Ventura of the Chicago White Sox in 1995; Chris Hoiles of the Orioles in 1998; Fernando Tatis of the St. Louis Cardinals in 1999; Nomar Garciaparra of the Red Sox in 1999; Bill Mueller of the Red Sox in 2003; and Josh Willingham of the Washington Nationals in 2009.
Cloninger remained the sole National League batter with two grand slams in a game until Tatis did it; and Tatis went one better by hitting both of his slams in the same inning. Mueller, a switch hitter, hit one slam as a right-handed batter and one as a lefty; he also hit a solo homer earlier in the game.
Cloninger hit one more home run in 1966, giving him five for the season; he also hit .234 with 23 runs batted in that year. The Braves traded him to the Cincinnati Reds in 1968; he hit two homers that season, one in 1969, and two more in 1970 to finish his career with 11 home runs. His career bating average was .192, which isn’t too bad for a pitcher.
Tony Cloninger finished his career with a 113-97 record as a pitcher. But because of one big night at the plate in July of 1966, he always will be remembered as a hitter.
(All statistics are from retrosheet.org)
So the Braves fired manager Fredi Gonzalez. It seems a bit unfair for him to get the ax after upper management decimated the team in an effort to rebuild the farm system. I figured the Braves would at least let him oversee the disaster of this season, but now they have decided to bring Brian Snitker on board to rearrange the deck chairs on the Titanic.
I’m not saying that Gonzalez ever was a good manager. The Braves should have fired him the first time he trotted out to home plate with a lineup card that had the pitcher batting eighth. (I don’t care if Tony La Russa used to do it, it’s still stupid.) Or maybe they should have fired him after the collapse of September 2011 when the team blew an eight-and-a-half-game lead in the Wild Card race. Or perhaps they should have fired him after the 2013 National League Division Series when he sat in the dugout in the bottom of the eighth inning of the deciding game and watched David Carpenter give up a two-run homer to Juan Uribe while a rested Craig Kimbrel stood watching from the bullpen mound. The Braves might have been justified in firing Gonzalez after their collapse in September 2014 when the team went 4-16 down the stretch.
So if the Braves stuck with Gonzalez when they actually had a chance to win, why are they firing him now when upper management knew 2016 was going to be a terrible season? It’s not like the Braves gave Gonzalez the 1927 Yankees to work with this season. They were 9-28 under Gonzalez; that’s a .243 winning percentage. Heck, at that rate they will have to improve their play to even be the 1962 Mets. At least Gonzalez and the Braves set the bar for success really low for Snitker.
But the current plight of the Braves has nothing to do with the competence, or incompetence, of their manager. I could give you some numbers that show that the Braves’ offense has been really bad, their defense is fairly lousy, and their bullpen is not very good. I also could give you some numbers that show their starting pitching actually hasn’t been that bad. But a really telling statistic to look at that demonstrates just how weak the Braves have been this season is their home run total.
Through 37 games under Gonzalez, the Braves had but 11 home runs as a team. The Philadelphia Phillies have the next-lowest total of home runs for a team this year with 29. Four players have more home runs individually at this point in the season than the Braves have as a team and seven more have just as many.
In Gonzalez’s last game as manager, Jeff Francoeur and Kelly Johnson each hit their first home runs of the season, doubling the number of players on the Braves’ current roster who had homered this year. That’s right. As of May 17 the Braves had but four players on their roster who had hit a home run this season. In addition to Francoeur and Johnson, Freddie Freeman had six home runs and rookie Mallex Smith had one. Drew Stubbs and Adonis Garcia each hit homers this season, but the Braves released Stubbs on May 3 and sent Garcia to the minors on May 7.
The Mets have two pitchers on their roster who have homered this season. One of them, Noah Syndergaard, hit two in one game and the other one, Bartolo Colon, is 42 years old and shaped like Baloo (the Phil Harris version) from The Jungle Book.
The 1962 Mets hit 139 home runs, led by Frank Thomas with 34. The 2016 Braves are on pace to hit around 48 homers as a team. I know hitting home runs doesn’t automatically make a team good, but a team that has virtually no power cannot be competitive. The Braves sent Gonzalez into battle this season with no ammunition and then fired him when he got routed.
It’s painful enough to try to follow a team with a .243 winning percentage, but the lack of power from the Braves adds insult to injury. The Braves stormed into Atlanta in 1966 and established themselves as a power-hitting team. Led by Henry Aaron (44), Joe Torre (36), Felipe Alou (31), and Mack Jones (23), the 1966 Braves pounded 207 home runs.
I don’t want to sound greedy by wishing for the likes of Aaron, Torre, Alou, and Jones; at this point I’d settle for the power of Gary Geiger with his four homers in 1966 or Mike de la Hoz who, with his two home runs that year, suddenly looks like a slugger. Heck, give me Tony Cloninger, a pitcher for goodness sake, who hit five home runs in 1966.
Both the 2016 Braves and the 1962 Mets started their seasons with nine straight losses. The 1962 New York Mets were an expansion team, so they have an excuse for getting out of the gate slowly and finishing at 40-120. (One game ended in a tie and they did not make up one rainout.) The Braves are rationalizing their poor record by reminding anyone still willing to listen that they are rebuilding. The firing of Gonzalez means they are still in the demolition phase of the project.
I realize the rebuilding process can be painful for the fans. The Braves claim to be doing the same thing the Houston Astros and Kansas City Royals did to make their teams strong. It appears that the Braves now have a farm system stocked with prime prospects. But the Braves’ performance in the early part of this season points to a bigger issue. It may be time for Major League Baseball to step in with some incentives to make sure its teams are at least trying to be competitive. Maybe a team should drop a slot in the amateur draft for each game over 100 they lose. After all, a team doesn’t have to be all that good to avoid losing 100 games.
Buckle up, Braves fans. We’re in for a bumpy ride this summer. It’s only the middle of May and we’re reduced to hoping the team can win more games than the 1962 Mets. And maybe Fredi Gonzalez should be grateful that he won’t be along for the ride.
(All statistics are from Baseball-Reference.com)
Baseball fans in middle Tennessee have a great option for good baseball this summer. The Nashville Sounds, Triple-A affiliate of the Oakland Athletics, have a really good team and they are loaded with fine young players. It’s worth a trip to Nashville to see Oakland’s third baseman of the future, Renato Nunez, alone.
According to the 2016 Sporting News Baseball Yearbook, Nunez is one of four of Oakland’s top ten prospects playing in Nashville this season. Shortstop, Chad Pinder is rated as Oakland’s third-best prospect; first baseman/outfielder, Matt Olson is eighth; starting pitcher, Dillon Overton is ninth; and Nunez, rounds out the list at number 10.
Nashville started the season with Oakland’s number-two prospect on their roster. Left-hander, Sean Manaea, quickly went 2-0 with a 1.50 earned run average in his first three starts so the Athletics called him up to the big club.
Of all of the prospects on the Nashville roster, Nunez is off to the best start. After a hot homestand that ended May 9, he is leading the team in hitting at .290 and in runs batted in with 16, and is tied with Max Muncy for the team lead in home runs with five.
Oakland signed Nunez as a non-drafted free agent out of Valencia, Carabobo, Venezuela when he was just 16 years old. The 6’ 1” right-handed hitter has shown power at every stop on his minor league tour. He hit 19 homers for Beloit in 2013 and followed that with 29 home runs for Stockton in 2014. At Double-A Midland last year, Nunez slammed 18 homers in just 93 games.
Nunez has a nice, compact swing that packs plenty of punch. And from what I’ve seen of him, he is patient at the plate. He is willing to take what the pitcher gives him and drive the ball to any part of the park.
Pinder is off to a bit of a slow start at the Triple-A level; he’s hitting .200 with a homer and nine RBIs. But Pinder was Oakland’s Minor League Player of the Year last year after hitting .317 with 15 home runs, and 86 RBIs for Midland, so fans in Nashville likely are going to see more production from him as the season goes forward.
Olson also is off to a slow start in Music City. He’s hitting just .167 with three homers and 10 RBIs; he also is striking out at an alarming rate. But two seasons ago, he slammed 37 home runs, so the potential is there for him to start driving the ball over the wall.
Overton, a 24-year-old lefty, has made five starts and his record stands at 1-3 with a 4.68 ERA; he also has given up 41 hits in 32 ⅔ innings. But Overton has 41 strikeouts with just five walks, so he is showing early signs of developing into a dominant starting pitcher.
Following minor league baseball really is all about watching the prospects. But if you like to see good baseball, the Sounds are delivering on that front, as well. A month into the season, they have been very competitive and easily could be better than their 14-17 record through games of May 9 indicates. And, of course, the Sounds play their home games in beautiful First Tennessee Park, so going to the games is a great all-around experience for the fans.
Chad Pinder, Matt Olson, and Dillon Overton may be a ways away from following Sean Manaea to Oakland; but if you want to get a glimpse of Renato Nunez, you might want to get down to First Tennessee Park during the next couple of homestands or you just might miss your chance.
(All statistics and biographical information in this article are from nashville.sounds.milb.com and Inside Pitch, the Official Game Day Publication of the Nashville Sounds.)
On April 6, 1973–a date which will live in infamy–Major League Baseball was suddenly and deliberately attacked by forces who wanted a more offensive game. That was the day Ron Blomberg of the New York Yankees stepped to the plate as baseball’s first designated hitter. Baseball hasn’t quite been the same since. The DH initially was a malady suffered only in the American League; but like a slow-moving virus, it gradually has infected most other areas of the game.
The DH appeared only in regular-season American League games until 1976 when MLB decided to allow it in World Series games played in American League parks. It took 16 years for the DH to rear its ugly head in an All-Star Game and by 2011 Major League Baseball decided to use the DH in the All-Star Game no matter the venue.
Interleague play, another abomination, started in 1997 and with it came the first DH to appear in a regular-season National League game. So what started out as an American League phenomenon is now practically ubiquitous.
Now that the DH is so firmly ensconced in the fabric of the game, there are those who want to deliver the final blow to baseball purists everywhere and have the DH now, the DH tomorrow, the DH forever in every ballpark, every night, in every league.
In the “Point After” feature of the May 11, 2015 issue of Sports Illustrated, Michael Rosenberg attempts to make the case for “all DH, all the time.” But in attempting to tell us why baseball should use the DH universally, he actually gives some good reasons why such a change is a bad idea.
Rosenberg’s starts out by saying, “The DH is a hot topic because Cardinals ace Adam Wainwright tore his Achilles tendon running to first base on a pop-up….” Rosenberg then says, “The problem is not that pitchers get injured while hitting; they are far more likely to get injured while pitching.” On this point, I agree with him.
Then Rosenberg says that the problem with the current system is that it calls for two sets of rules, depending on which league the home team represents. He’s right, but eliminating the DH would solve this problem much more effectively.
It’s at this point that Rosenberg really goes off the rails. “The game of baseball is more interesting with a DH,” he says. To make his case, he concedes that the DH eliminates the double switch, but then asks, “What would you rather see: David Ortiz bat or Terry Collins scribble on his lineup card?” Obviously, Rosenberg doesn’t understand the double switch well enough to know that it involves a lot more than a manager making changes on a lineup card.
Another point Rosenberg makes is, “The DH allows the top starters to throw longer into games because their managers don’t pull them for pinch hitters.” So in the late innings of a close game with the DH, a manager doesn’t have to decide whether to bat for his pitcher or leave him in the game. In fact, with the DH, the manager doesn’t have to do much thinking at all. So if you don’t want to have to think–as a manager or as a fan–then “all DH, all the time” is the game for you.
In fact, I wonder whether anyone who prefers the game of baseball with the DH understands the Grand Old Game well enough to make an intelligent argument for why the DH should be used at all, much less “all the time.”
Orlando Cepeda: the Original DH
I remember one of the major selling points of the DH was that it would give aging stars with limited mobility a chance to stick around the game. Orlando Cepeda wrapped up the 1972 season with the Oakland Athletics on knees that were so rickety he barely could walk. The Athletics, whose owner, Charles Finley, was the leading proponent of the DH, released Cepeda on December 18, 1972. Less than a month later, the 24 owners voted to allow the American League to use a “designated pinch-hitter” for the pitchers. A week after the vote Cepeda latched on with the Boston Red Sox.
Cepeda had a decent season in the first year of the DH, batting .289 with 20 home runs and 86 runs batted in with Red Sox. It’s ironic that Finley had the prototypical DH on his roster while he was lobbying the other owners to adopt the DH, but released him just 24 days before the rules changed.
But things did not end well for Cepeda in Boston. The Red Sox quickly realized that Cepeda clogged up the base paths whenever he didn’t hit a homer so, despite his good numbers with the bat, they released him at the end of Spring Training in 1974. Pretty soon teams realized that having guys like Cepeda limp (or guys like Gates Brown waddle) to the plate four times a game wasn’t necessarily a good thing, so the completely immobile DH gradually fell by the wayside.
I’m hoping for the day when some player like Ron Blomberg descends into the dugout having made the last appearance as a designated hitter in baseball history.
(all statistics are from Baseball-Reference.com)